Thursday, April 3, 2008

For Rum...where is the rum?

Truly, hit and miss/random chance composition is the composition of our era. It is rife through commercial music (the stuff of bands, not the stuff of pop singers who could not be more removed from hit and miss composition if they jumped on a boat to the Antarctic), it certainly appears to be the main mode of music creation amongst the electronic noise artists, even the Classicists sometimes abandon themselves to formulas (take Serialism for example). So, today in forum we found out about a French, Music Concrete fellow named Pierre. I wouldn't say so much that this guy is a composer of one kind or the other, more a fanatic of sound. Sound is his instrument, he has a library of samples as long as my arm and the means to summon them at will (almost, and with the aid of his wife Bernadette). His compositions consist of to my interpretation, simple improvisation with his samples as the notes on his instrument. Of the works that we heard, I much preferred his collaboration with standard rock music than his pure noise works (with Pierre referring to his best known Rock music collaboration as being to him as The Bolero was to Ravel...to both these composers I say - lighten up, perhaps the people like these because they sound good, perhaps a good composition is not necessarily a technical one!). Amazingly enough, his remixed Classical music features standard mainstream techno beats, these works have aged quite well...

2 comments:

John said...

Hey,

Just been reading your thoughts from the last few weeks of forum. Let me say, I agree entirely with the idea of pre-meditated composition, but within the context of this course, it is something I've had to temporarily let go of from time to time, lest I fail my assignment! The ambience generator I presented in Week 3 was an attempt to satisfy the MaxMSP course requirements, but hopefully some degree of personal satisfaction too. Having said that, I wouldn't normally compose an ambient piece that way, unless I wanted some of the control taken away from me.

In the case of Pierre Henry, I agree he is definitely attracted to raw sounds as such. I liked his remixes, particularly over the funk oriented material, as his sounds give it a psychedelic flavour. His compositions are hit and miss in my view. He's like a fisherman catching many different varieties of fish, then dumping it all in a big basket and handing it to us - "here you sort it out!"

Stephen said...

My experience is that composition in all its forms is 'hit and miss' - even the greatest artists in all genres have a few misses. Maybe it's the proportion of hits to misses that determines how good you are. I guess most people would be satisfied with just one chart-topper - that would pay the bills for a long, long time. I notice that many students relate best to the pieces by Henry that contain things that cen relate to - eg a beat, rock, etc Familiarity is a powerful attractor.